T. Budreika, an economist at the Ministry of Economy and Innovation: Diesel prices are approaching 2.5 euros. What should the government do?
Lithuania is engulfed in discussions about rising fuel prices. The highest price recorded on gas station signs today reached 2.37 euros, but even though the price of crude oil on the markets has been falling in recent weeks, prices will remain high due to reduced capacity at diesel refineries.
Additional uncertainty was caused by President Trump’s statement that he is considering banning diesel exports from the U.S. The likelihood of this happening is quite high, as high fuel prices have become a major political issue during the U.S. midterm election campaign. The phrase “it’s the economy, stupid” is well understood in the U.S., especially by this administration.
In that case, the price of diesel would jump past the 2.5-euro mark. A prolonged shock would mean not only more expensive fuel, but also higher inflation, a more expensive currency, and slower economic growth. But what does this mean for household expenses?
How much does the spike in fuel prices cost a family?
The average household’s disposable income is approximately 2,000 euros per month. Of that, we spend an average of about 310 euros on transportation, and specifically about 200 euros on fuel.
Since the beginning of the year, the average price of diesel has risen from 1.53 to about 2.25 euros, or 47 percent. If a family does not change its fuel consumption habits – driving the same amount, not reducing speed, and not switching to public transportation – its fuel costs have already increased by an additional 94 euros per month. In recent years, monthly household income has increased by approximately 140 euros; therefore, when considering the rise in fuel costs alone, affordability has not decreased on average.
Averages do not reflect the full picture
But averages often mask a highly uneven situation. In the real economy, income growth is distributed unevenly – that is, some people’s wages are rising rapidly, while others’ are not. Therefore, a segment of society, especially in the regions, justifiably feels that their situation is deteriorating.
However, in economics, there is always a link between price and consumption. Households can choose alternatives and reduce their consumption. However, these alternatives are more accessible in major cities. Nearly 40 percent of Lithuania’s total population lives in Vilnius, Kaunas, and Klaipėda; in response to rising fuel prices, they can choose public transportation, and we are already seeing this reflected in overall fuel consumption statistics.
As fuel prices rise, consumption changes
In May, during the previous price spike, diesel consumption was about 10 percent lower than a year ago. We don’t have the September data yet, but it’s likely that higher prices will reduce consumption once again.
What might explain at least part of this decline? People are watching their spending. Faced with high fuel prices, they’re choosing to drive less and use public transportation, more fuel-efficient cars, or electric vehicles more often. In the context of high oil prices, electric cars are no longer chosen solely for their “green” credentials. A household that spent about 200 euros per month on fuel before the price shock now spends about 294 euros for the same amount of travel. Traveling a similar distance in an electric car would cost about 90 euros in electricity – that’s more than 200 euros less per month, and even less if you have a solar power system.
Of course, this isn’t a solution for everyone. Buying a car is a major investment, and there is still a lack of charging infrastructure in rural areas; the capacity of the power grid is also a key factor. However, change is already underway. The number of EVs and plug-in hybrids on Lithuanian roads has increased by approximately 15,000 this year – or about one-third – though they still account for only about 3.5 percent of the active vehicle fleet.
Since diesel is subject to a 21 percent VAT rate, as prices rise, so do the government’s VAT revenues. With the price of diesel rising from 1.53 to 2.25 euros, we pay the government approximately 12.5 cents more in VAT per liter. Meanwhile, excise tax depends on the volume of fuel sold, not its price; therefore, as consumption declines, so do excise tax revenues to the budget.
Cut taxes or invest in resilience?
Politicians naturally feel compelled to respond to the crisis that most of us are personally experiencing. The simplest solution – as the Latvians have done – is to cut fuel taxes. Partial compensation through excise tax cuts is possible and worth considering, but it would send a signal to the market that “don’t worry about energy efficiency.” And it’s worth thinking about that.
The most sensible use of this additional VAT revenue is to ensure that the next oil price shock is felt less acutely by Lithuanian residents and businesses – by accelerating the electrification of industry, transportation companies, and households.
In addition, it makes sense to invest in projects that increase electricity supply and grid capacity in Lithuania. In the short term, measures such as the electricity price credit for energy-intensive companies proposed by the President could also be used – allowing a portion of electricity infrastructure costs to be paid later, when the energy situation is more favorable. However, the long-term solution must be greater electrification and lower electricity prices.
The cost of electricity is becoming a competitiveness issue
Electricity is currently cheaper for Lithuanian companies than the EU average, but twice as expensive as in China and nearly three times as expensive as in the U.S. This undermines our competitiveness and electrification efforts.
And it is precisely down this path – despite all the rhetoric – that the world’s major economies are rapidly moving in an effort to reduce their dependence on fossil fuels. China is already significantly more electrified than Lithuania: electricity accounts for about 28 percent of final energy consumption there, compared to 23.4 percent in the EU, 22 percent in the U.S., and just 16.5 percent in Lithuania.
We must be less dependent when the next oil shock hits
If we want a more competitive industrial sector and lower transportation costs for residents, we must use this crisis to ensure that next time we are less dependent on global oil prices.
